go to vampirefreaks main page

vampirefreaks messageboard
   > Intelligent Discussion

New Topic New Poll
  
<PREVIOUS 1 2 3 4 NEXT>

Vermin

[forum info] [PM]
GanDILF
Axis Owns

Posts: 20248


Is the Catholic church a force for good?
September 14, 2010, 01:00pm
|
This isn't a "Does God exist" discussion, and I'll be deleting digressions down that path.

Focussing purely on non-metaphysical issues, is the Roman Catholic church a force for good in the modern world? Or is it a harmful anachronism?

bloodystyx
[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 2
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 21, 2010, 01:15pm
|

ofcoure,it`s better for all...mmhmm we have protestant churches and chatholics churches...we neede they..hehe.....when you have only one chuch,than people are fighting....


AyatollaOfRocknRolla

[forum info] [PM]

Posts: 4321
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 21, 2010, 11:00pm
|

Wow, a slight tangent in relation to the Catholic churc - just found out that the Pope, if not a uturn at least a segway, has loosened the official stance on condoms in relation to the HIV/AIDS crisis in Africa.

Wow. Just wow.


musicalheartache

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 12
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 22, 2010, 07:11pm
|

Hahah. Religion is cute.
Let us pull together the gays, goths, witches, and nonbelievers into a pile and set them on fire at the stake!
And they look down on the ancient religions that used to sacrifice humans, when their followers still indirectly do such.
I do believe not too long ago some poor girl's prom as picketed by a nearby church because she wanted to wear a tuxedo. -.-"
I like how they say God created everyone equal and all that love one another bullshit, singing their little songs about good Samaritans, then turn around and abuse their children.
I don't think religion is directly tied to child abuse, but every child I know who has been abused belonged to a strict, uptight, Catholic family.
So my vote is no. To picket people for such minor things or beat their children and wives and then kiss up at church to some All-Seeing Being they believe in?
Yeah. Right.


Helloween_1985

[forum info] [PM]
I AM IRON MAN
Rebel Rouser
Not very bright.
Posts: 10394
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 23, 2010, 05:06am
|

"Let us pull together the gays, goths, witches, and nonbelievers into a pile and set them on fire at the stake!"

The middle ages called..they want you back home

"And they look down on the ancient religions that used to sacrifice humans, when their followers still indirectly do such"

I haven't met or seen Christians who sacrifice people, only person who did sacrifice himself was Jesus.


-SKOLL-

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 1621
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 23, 2010, 03:49pm
|

sending people off to war while crying 'deus vult' counts as sacrifice.

the level of assurance one has in their sanity is inversely proportional to the actual level of ones sanity.
we are all mad here.


Helloween_1985

[forum info] [PM]
I AM IRON MAN
Rebel Rouser
Not very bright.
Posts: 10397
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 23, 2010, 05:10pm
|

"sending people off to war while crying 'deus vult' counts as sacrifice"

I have no idea what "deus vult" means, but I'm assuming it's latin


GeHeImE138

[forum info] [PM]
Myrmidon
Posts: 813
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 23, 2010, 09:41pm
|

It was the war cry for the first crusade. It means "God wills it".

"The constitutions of most of our States assert that all power is inherent in the people; that... it is their right and duty to be at all times armed."

-Thomas Jefferson


CybernetikAssassin

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 102
Is the Catholic church a force for good? November 24, 2010, 09:35am
|

ExternalSolipsism
"Upon the fall of Nazism in Germany after WWII, Church officials aided Nazis in escaping Europe to avoid prosecution for war crimes, and potentially with the additional goal of attempting to re-establish a new Fourth Reich. Is this a force for good in the world?"

This is the first I've ever heard of that. God knows what else they've done ._.


Code

[forum info] [PM]
Kelly's Forever Newb

VF Awards 2012
Most Fuckable!
Posts: 2103
Is the Catholic church a force for good? May 30, 2012, 09:10am
|

These are pretty long but Stephen Fry (as usual) makes a fairly solid case against the church itself being a force of good.
part 1 Part 2


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 3
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 01, 2012, 11:00pm
|

The Catholic Church was tragically subverted and its political power was neutered after Vatican 2.0 in 1962. It was the Catholic church that stood up to the filthy degenerates in Hollywood who were producing movies with nudity, blasphemy and ridicule of the clergy in the 1920's and 30's until a Catholic boycott put Hollywood in its [moral] place. After 1965, they ran up the white flag when John Courtney Murray said in Time magazine "no more catholic boycotts, were going to engage in dialogue", which was a really stupid move that destroyed the ability of the Catholic Church to do good by destroying its political power.

Dr. E. Michael Jones explains this in his lectures.

www.culturewars.com/Podcasts.html

IMHO, in order for the Catholic Church to do good, as demonstrated, in the example above, they need a 'divorce' from the bad alliance they made in Vatican 2.0 and simply get back to basics.

Edited by: sicutrosa at June 02, 2012, 07:50pm


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 4
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 02, 2012, 07:45pm
|

deskatwoman
"I believe that the higher ranks of the Catholic Church have been very underhanded and corrupt for a very long time, maybe even so far back as the foundation of the tradition itself. "

What exactly do you base that statement on? [sources?]
Are you aware of the Medieval period in European history - that is to say, the story that is NOT propagated by current academia?

"Humans twist faith into ugly things."

Typical modern academic propaganda to sanction any attack on the Catholic church. Notice how this statement is NEVER used against any other faith....Apparently, only Christians are barbaric.... /sarcasm

"I think most modern Catholics (at least in my area) are much more realistic and open in practicing the Faith than the Vatican sanctioned, out of touch high clergy ever could be. "

This doesn't even make sense. Traditionally, the Catholic church is OPPOSED to condoms and OPPOSED to abortion, which means the Vatican would not allow these assertions. How is the "modern" catholic church "out of touch" when Ratzinger starts to condone secularist ideas such as condom use? It wouldn't surprise me if Ratzinger condoned abortion in the very near future... This so-called "Vatican" is very far from the "traditional catholic church" against which you and your modernist ilk love to rant.

Thus far, you and your modernist ilk [through the mainstream media vis-a-vis the scandals] have managed to get the church to agree to condom use and very soon, abortions. One wonders what else you will want the Catholic Church to condone, whilst at the same time blatantly criticizing her for her allegedly "evil" past...

Edited by: sicutrosa at June 02, 2012, 07:47pm


Code

[forum info] [PM]
Kelly's Forever Newb

VF Awards 2012
Most Fuckable!
Posts: 2158
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 03, 2012, 09:37am
|

She just likes to ramble whilst making little sense.


Karas

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 20
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 04, 2012, 03:05pm
|

Throughout time the catholic church the vatican has proven over and over it is a force for itself whenever they claim to be that is all. The vatican will always do what is good for the vatican and that is all they will change what dogma they teach in order to reinforce their decisions

Violence isnt the only answer... but its most fun.

ulven
[forum info] [PM]
[online]
Posts: 9
June 07, 2012, 09:12am
|

Edited by: ulven at June 07, 2012, 09:15am


Binaco

[forum info] [PM]
They're watching you
Posts: 118
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 10, 2012, 04:45pm
|

If you take the Catholic Church literally from the highly intuitive level and try to judge things, you'll go mad. Certain things I know about the human youth-pot-roast level in general consciousness you were born with.


KrisLucif

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 4
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 16, 2012, 01:06pm
|

its a force for money and spiritual supression. oh yeah- and their priests rape kids. So yeah- they're evil twisted fucks


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 5
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 17, 2012, 12:34am
|

"She just likes to ramble whilst making little sense."

...And you like to ramble for the sake of rambling...

Anything else, Ramblin' man?


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 6
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 17, 2012, 12:38am
|

"The vatican will always do what is good for the vatican"

After Vatican 2.0, I will agree with that statement. But before Vatican 2.0, I disagree.

Edited by: sicutrosa at June 17, 2012, 12:38am


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 7
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 17, 2012, 12:55am
|

"Upon the fall of Nazism in Germany after WWII, Church officials aided Nazis in escaping Europe to avoid prosecution for war crimes, and potentially with the additional goal of attempting to re-establish a new Fourth Reich. Is this a force for good in the world?"

Who are YOU to judge what happened during WW2? Are you absolutely certain of ALL the facts of WW2? I seriously doubt it. You only know what YOUR 'history indoctrinators' have told you...other than that, YOU are totally clueless as to what happened in WW2. Remember, there is ALWAYS TWO [or more] sides to ANY history...And in this case, it is CLEAR that the victors always get the PRIVILEGE of writing "history" in any way they see to fit their agenda.


KrisLucif

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 5
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 18, 2012, 03:59pm
|

who are you to say another cant judge or have an opinion? better yet- who are you to judge anothers knowledge and conclusion? Everyone can have an opinion and belief- you dont get to shoot them down. NO ONE is absolutely certain about a damn thing that they havent personally experienced but everyone can do their homework and come up with a history that resonates with them. And I and plenty of others dont "ONLY KNOW WHAT HISTORY INDOCTRINATORS HAVE TOLD US". I read and research all sides of the issues and dont take anything for face value. I have family who were in the war and I'll take their accounts over any writer or professionals opinion any day. that includes randoms on a message board


HitlersMoustache

[forum info] [PM]
Chuir mé

an scriú

i dtuinnín


Is dócha nach bhfuil seans ar bith ann?
Posts: 24359
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 18, 2012, 04:13pm
|

'You only know what YOUR 'history indoctrinators' have told you...other than that, YOU are totally clueless as to what happened in WW2.'

Did you fight in World War Two? If not, aren't you doing pretty much the same thing that you're insulting other users for doing?


breathquiet

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 14
Is the Catholic church a force for good? June 21, 2012, 09:33am
|

When people say "Only God can judge me" I simply reply, "Only I can judge me".


AyatollaOfRocknRolla

[forum info] [PM]

Posts: 4634
Is the Catholic church a force for good? July 10, 2012, 10:21am
|

"(that incense ball thing... who doesn't like incense?)"

Emphysemics? ;-)


Binaco

[forum info] [PM]
They're watching you
Posts: 135
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 11, 2012, 04:45pm
|

It's an excuse and a sorter of good stuff though contrary in various respects to the REAL fist son of Mary, like in HE-idol driven pride egocentrically that men dig - it's the hows of such rhythm discovery. Do not mess with humans who know this rhythm within at large.


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 13
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 11, 2012, 10:27pm
|

HitlersMoustache

"Did you fight in World War Two? If not, aren't you doing pretty much the same thing that you're insulting other users for doing? "

That is an easy escape for pacifists like yourself. You prefer others to do the DIRTY work for you whilst you watch and sip your Pinot Noir. Do you know that most Americans were OPPOSED to the involvement in WW2? I guess your history teachers didn't tell you that eh?

Nice try... Do you have anything else to contribute as to why the Catholic Church should NOT be a force for good, other than the blatant lies and false propaganda from your history teachers?


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 14
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 11, 2012, 10:37pm
|

krislucif

"I read and research all sides of the issues and dont take anything for face value."

I have already provided the name of my source of scholarly research. YOU have NOT provided YOUR source(s)... And I'm still waiting, Mr, "one post wonder"...

The onus is on YOU to provide such scholarly sources, otherwise it is YOU who will not be taken seriously.

BTW, when I say scholarly sources, I mean ALL scholars, both those who are in AND those who were (kicked) out of academia, because nine out of ten times, the ones who were kicked out of academia are the ones who most often speak the truth - you cannot deny this fact. And if you do, it will only serve to prove that you academic elites have something to hide.


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 15
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 11, 2012, 10:50pm
|

KrisLucif

"its a force for money and spiritual supression. oh yeah- and their priests rape kids. So yeah- they're evil twisted fucks "

So says your mainstream media, who, every time there is a conflict in the middle east, and the Catholic Church voices their opposition to the wars, violence and the killing of innocent Palestinians, the mainstream media goes into high gear, bringing into the forefront some sexual scandal that supposedly occurred 40+ years ago, of which they have absolutely NO proof whatsoever.

Have you anything else to say, Mr. "Minister of Anti-Catholic Propaganda"?

Where are your scholarly sources for such a statement?

Do you have any?

Mind you, the mainstream media does this to DISTRACT the "sheeple" like yourself from what is REALLY occurring in the middle east.

As a good Catholic, I actually feel sorry for people like you who cannot see the truth in these turbulent times.

Edited by: sicutrosa at August 11, 2012, 10:54pm


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 16
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 11, 2012, 10:57pm
|

Alexander2

"That does not mean to say the Holy Mother does not have issues. "

Meaning?

**gets popcorn**


sicutrosa

[forum info] [PM]
Posts: 17
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 11, 2012, 11:18pm
|

HitlersMoustache

"you're insulting other users"

But it's ok for other users to insult MY Catholic faith is that it?

Is it ok for other users to post responses to this thread and use defamatory terminology such as "raping kids" when referring the Catholic Church?

I think it's YOUR credibility that is at stake here, not mine.

Just out of curiosity, is it ok for someone to post defamatory statements against any other religion?

Yeah, I thought not. It's only Christianity that can [LEGALLY] be bashed to "kingdom come" right?

So much for "Intelligent Discussion"...


Helloween_1985

[forum info] [PM]
I AM IRON MAN
Rebel Rouser
Not very bright.
Posts: 12270
Is the Catholic church a force for good? August 12, 2012, 04:14am
|

"Is it ok for other users to post responses to this thread and use defamatory terminology such as "raping kids" when referring the Catholic Church?"

Why should we pretend the Catholic Church is a force for good when it's been reported that the Chruch themselves knew what was going on, and even went as far to give the rapists high up jobs?

"occurred 40+ years ago, of which they have absolutely NO proof whatsoever"

The Church covered it up, would you trust an organisation who condemned rape, but 40's ago done the same thing?

Edited by: Helloween_1985 at August 12, 2012, 04:26am


<PREVIOUS 1 2 3 4 NEXT>

Leave a comment:
Subject:
Comment:
Preview    Include Signature   

[ Show Emotes ] [ Edit Signature ]


vampirefreaks messageboard - Intelligent Discussion

Reality Check ( page 2 ) Last Comment by lovestocuddle
Religion and how u marry... ( page 2 3 ) Last Comment by Murcielago
A Nation of Healers
Thoughts on Karma and Reincarnation Last Comment by idiot62
Should we ban internships? Last Comment by The_Corpsie
Jump To:


[ VF Points: 0 ]   [ Points Today: ]
[ Terms of Service ] [ About ] [ Getting Started ] [ FAQ ] [ Privacy Policy ]
© VampireFreaks.com / Synth-tec Inc. 2013   All Rights Reserved